
These Are the Worst High Schools in Idaho According to National Report
When it comes to education in Idaho, some schools shine brightly for their academic performance. U.S. News & World Report recently released their rankings of top high schools across the nation.
The annual ranking doesn’t just highlight the Idaho schools who are top performers. The data also gives us a clearer picture of schools where there is room for improvement.
READ MORE: Idaho’s Top 10 High Schools Ranked for 2025-2026 School Year
The publication included 24,000 high schools across the nation in its most recent set of rankings, including 157 Idaho high schools. Six factors went into establishing a final score for each of the schools on the list. Here’s a look at those factors and how much of the total score they made up:
- College Readiness 30%
- State Assessment Proficiency 20%
- State Assessment Performance 20%
- Underserved Student Performance 10%
- College Curriculum Breadth 10%
- Graduation Rate 10%
We’ve already taken a look at the top performing schools on the list, but now it's time to flip the script and look at which Idaho high schools landed near the bottom.

While these schools may rank lower on the list, that doesn’t mean they aren’t full of hard-working students and teachers who want to see them excel, but it does highlight unique challenges some communities face.
Once U.S. News & World Report reached #104, these schools were all given a rank of “#104-157 in Idaho rankings.” Some have high graduation rates, but their low or nonexistent college readiness schools dropped them to the bottom of the list.
Author's Note: This article breaks down data that was already made public. It is simply an extraction of Idaho data from a national report and does not reflect the views of our station.
Wilder Middle/High School - Wilder, ID
- Graduation Rate - 91% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 143
- 100% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Wendell High School - Wendell, ID
- Graduation Rate - 71% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 329
- Reading Proficiency - 62%
Weiser High School - Weiser, ID
- Graduation Rate - 82% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 529
- Mathematics Proficiency - 29% | Reading Proficiency - 64%
Teton High School - Driggs, ID
- Graduation Rate - 90% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 606
- Reading Proficiency - 47%
Technical Careers High School - Idaho Falls, ID
- Graduation Rate - 95% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 107
- 15% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Sugar-Salem High School - Sugar City, ID
- Graduation Rate - 91% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 591
- Mathematics Proficiency - 30% | Reading Proficiency - 43%
Snake River High School - Blackfoot, ID
- Graduation Rate - 96% | College Readiness - 13.1 | Enrollment 9-12 - 603
- Reading Proficiency - 41%
Shelley Senior High School - Shelley, ID
- Graduation Rate - 91% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 785
- Reading Proficiency - 49%
Salmon High School - Salmon, ID
- Graduation Rate - 74% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 236
- Mathematics Proficiency - 21% | Reading Proficiency 41%
Ririe High School - Ririe, ID
- Graduation Rate - 83% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 233
- Mathematics Proficiency - 27% | Reading Proficiency - 60%
Rimrock Jr-Sr High School - Bruneau, ID
- Graduation Rate - 96% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 81
- Reading Proficiency - 45%
Priest River Lamanna High School - Priest River, ID
- Graduation Rate - 66% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 274
- 30% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Potlatch Jr/Sr High School - Potlatch, ID
- Graduation Rate - 94% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 128
- 25% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Payette High School - Payette, ID
- Graduation Rate - 79% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 364
- Reading Proficiency - 54%
Pathways in Education: Nampa - Nampa, ID
- Graduation Rate - 16% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 290
- Mathematics Proficiency - 0%
Parma High School - Parma, ID
- Graduation Rate - 95% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 330
- Reading Proficiency - 60%
Orofino High School - Orofino, ID
- Graduation Rate - 72% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 239
- Mathematics Proficiency - 20% | Reading Proficiency - 43%
North Fremont Jr-Sr High School - Ashton, ID
- Graduation Rate - 85% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 187
- 32% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
New Plymouth High School - New Plymouth, ID
- Graduation Rate - 94% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 290
- Reading Proficiency - 54%
Mountain Home Senior High School - Mountain Home
- Graduation Rate - 77% | College Readiness - 8.8 | Enrollment 9-12 - 894
- Mathematics Proficiency - 20% | Reading Proficiency - 45%
Melba High School - Melba, ID
- Graduation Rate - 87% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 268
- Mathematics Proficiency - 45% | Reading Proficiency - 57%
Lincoln High School - Idaho Falls, ID
- Graduation Rate - 60% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 136
- 37% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Lapwai High School - Lapwai, ID
- Graduation Rate - 76% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 149
- 21% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Lakeside High School - Plummer, ID
- Graduation Rate - 50% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 123
- 64% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Kuna High School - Kuna, ID
- Graduation Rate - 82% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 1,640
- Mathematics Proficiency - 29% | Reading Proficiency - 60%
Jerome High School - Jerome, ID
- Graduation Rate - 79% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 1,156
- Reading Proficiency - 44%
Kellogg High School - Kellogg, ID
- Graduation Rate - 82% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 300
- 36% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Idaho Technical Career Academy - Meridian, ID
- Graduation Rate - 67% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 -127
Idaho City High School - Idaho City, ID
- Graduation Rate -88% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 104
- Reading Proficiency - 51%
Homedale High School - Homedale, ID
- Graduation Rate - 92% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 410
- Science Proficiency - 15% | Reading Proficiency - 47%
Hansen Jr/Sr High School - Hansen, ID
- Graduation Rate - 75% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 88
- Reading Proficiency - 58%
Garden Valley School - Garden Valley, ID
- Graduation Rate - 88% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 94
- Mathematics Proficiency - 34% | Reading Proficiency - 46%
Filer High School - Filer, ID
- Graduation Rate - 79% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 488
- Reading Proficiency - 66%
Eagle Academy - Eagle, ID
- Graduation Rate - 47% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 190
- 39% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Council Jr/Sr High School - Council, ID
- Graduation Rate - 75% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 76
- 31% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Clearwater Valley Jr-Sr - Kooskia, ID
- Graduation Rate - 53% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 115
- Mathematics Proficiency - 32% | Reading Proficiency - 48%
Challis Jr-Sr High School - Challis, ID
- Graduation Rate - 70% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 100
- 36% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Burley Senior High School - Burley, ID
- Graduation Rate - 92% | College Readiness - 5.5 | Enrollment 9-12 - 1,024
- Mathematics Proficiency - 25% | Reading Proficiency - 42% | Science Proficiency - 30%
Buhl High School - Buhl, ID
- Graduation Rate - 78% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 365
- 36% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
Blackfoot High School - Blackfoot, ID
- Graduation Rate - 89% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 1,243
- Mathematics Proficiency - 28% | Reading Proficiency - 58%
Bennett Mountain High School - Mountain Home, ID
- Graduation Rate - 89% | College Readiness - 10.6 | Enrollment 9-12 - 103
- 49% of students considered economically disadvantaged by U.S. News & World Report
American Falls High School - American Falls, ID
- Graduation Rate - 86% | College Readiness - N/A | Enrollment 9-12 - 442
- Science Proficiency - 30% | Reading Proficiency - 50%
READ MORE: These 10 Idaho School Leaders Make the Most Money in the State
Gallery Credit: Michelle Heart


